![]() The judge said instants are not triggered abilities and triggered abilities are only on permanents. Nope, there's no triggered ability to counter. I said "I am not countering the card, I am countering the triggered ability." ![]() It contains a one-shot effect in the first instruction and a continuous effect (specifically a replacement effect) in the second instruction. It is on an instant and doesn't meet any of the criteria of 113.6 so is a spell ability. Any text on an instant or sorcery spell is a spell ability unless it's an activated ability, a triggered ability, or a static ability that fits the criteria described in rule 113.6. Spell abilities are abilities that are followed as instructions while an instant or sorcery spell is resolving. No, the whole paragraph is a spell ability. I asked if I could teferis protection to prevent it from being affected and he said no as the ornithopter was not mine and Mystic Reflection is a replacement effect so Teferi's Protection doesn't work. The hullbreaker came out and it turned into an ornithopter. I targetted a pilot token and he used mystic reflection and he targetted an ornithopter, I tried to counter, he said I couldn't so I said I would hold it for the trigger which I was wrong. I polimorphed, it got delayed, then on my upkeep 3 turns from there the polimorph went off. Yeah so I am running a Shorikai poly/tyrant. I tried to counter, he said I couldn't, so he targeted an ornithopter, I tried to stop the trigger, the judge said I couldn't so the hull break horror entered as an ornithopter.Īgain, there's no Triggered ability to counter. Then, begin to reveal till you hit the Hullbreaker Horror, then it's too late for the Mystic Reflection to do anything. If they allow the Polymorph to resolve, you Destroy the token. So, they don't know what, if anything, you would be putting onto the Battlefield. They can respond to the Spell, by casting the Reflection. ![]() You cast the Polymorph targeting your token. To expand on it I had just Polymorphed a token into a hull break horror and he casted Mystic Reflection in response When Mystic Reflection resolves, it creates a Replacement effect that will modify how the next one or more Creatures enter the Battlefield. When Mystic Reflection is Cast, only a Target is chosen. The next time one or more creatures or planeswalkers enter the battlefield this turn, they enter as copies of the chosen creature. It does not have a Triggered ability.Ĭhoose target nonlegendary creature. Mystic Reflection does not use any of those three words. Triggered abilities have a trigger condition and an effect. Triggered abilities always use the words "When", "Whenever" or "At".Ħ03.1. Return target legendary creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield.Such as Doublecast, First Day of Class, Goryo's Vengance Delayed Triggered abilities can be created by the resolution of a Spell/Ability. On that specific bit, the Judge was wrong. There was probably something on the board stopping it, so I said "I am not countering the card, I am countering the triggered ability." The judge was called and he said instants are not triggered abilities and triggered abilities are only on permanents. Is the second sentence of Mystic Reflection a triggered ability? The player's reasoning was that it was a clone, but it wasn't the clone it was the phrase, "the next time _ happens, do this." which is what I was wondering if that was a trigger statement and I could stop the trigger of it. I then used it after not knowing phasing wouldn't turn it back into the original creature. I also asked if I could Teferi's protection before hullbreak hit and he said that wouldn't work either. To expand on it I had just polymorphed a token into a hull break horror and he casted Mystic Reflection in response to the polymorph I tried to counter, he said I couldn't, so he targeted an ornithopter, I tried to stop the trigger, the judge said I couldn't so the hull break horror entered as an ornithopter. I had a disallow that I casted to counter it and he said it couldn't be countered (I don't remember his reasoning). Someone casted Mystic Reflection and told me some reason why I couldn't counter it. Hey guys, I hadn't played magic in a few months and have been playing some other games, so I was getting rules confused.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |